March 24, 2015 Madigan: "I wrote [Summers] about 'campaign' mode...LHA to take Lead....City Ought Not Be In Campaign"

[Brian Essi]

Note the emails below--some of which I just obtained after 6 months of stonewalling and delay from City Hall--4 months after the election.

So Summers, Madigan and two business leaders (David Stein and Paula Reed) are discussing and orchestrating a "campaign" that the city "ought not" be involved in.

So they want "LHA to to take the lead" (Summers, Madigan and Bullock are all part of LHA as elected leaders).

But Summers is telling Madigan the "materials" for the "campaign" will done soon for the "campaign" they "ought not be in."

And few days later CCF attorney Michael Meehan and CCF Trustee Tom Gable (i.e. LHA/CCF) send Butler hundreds of pages of stuff assembled and prepared by the CCF legal department which are immediately posted on the city website as is without review or edit and remain there today.

So Summers, Madigan, and Bullock together with corporate interests have, among other things, used a "charity" and public asset belonging to the city
in an admittedly improper "campaign" and also used the city website a a "campaign" tool for something they acknowledged they "ought not be" involved in.

LHA/CCF money funded the "Vote no on 64" campaign.

Note that Madigan used her private email account in the hope of evading scrutiny but she soliciting business leaders to come to Council, i.e. acting in her official capacity.


Butler, Kevin
From: Mary Madigan <mlmadigan9@hotmail.com>
Sent: Monday, March 23, 2015 11:11 PM
Subject: Meetings
Hi,
After tonight's meeting I decide we need to sit down with a few people and get a plan together. I also
thought this over the weekend after a meeting I had with Paula and David.
I know we don't have any more on the contract with Barb Paynter but I thnk we need more than
communications at this point anyway. I think we need to get a full outreach plan together including:
materials ‐ an FAQ, a palm card, talking points
speaker's training ‐ we can get a volunteer coach for interested supporters
list of events ‐ we all need to get out there and talk, including block watches and more L2L
We need to recalibrate our communications efforts. I'm concerned that the negativity is gettign ahead of the
possibility.
Can we talk tomorrow?
ML

From: Mary Madigan
To: Paula Reed; planthm@aol.com
Cc: Smith, Monique
Subject: COW Monday the 30th
Date: Tuesday, March 24, 2015 10:31:36 PM

Hi, Paula an David.

I hope you can both come to the next COW. This one will focus on development possibilities
for the footprint and how it may impact the rest of the downtown and the city.
I asked Patty Ryan and Ian to participate with Dru as the lead. Patty wrote a thoughtful letter
to council a couple weeks ago so she will talk about those ideas. Ian is key to the
conversation as a voice and resource for all. David, if you/DLBA have anything formal or
informal to present, I will make sure to make time for it, too. Even if you want to update us
on your outreach, that would be perfect.

I wrote an email to Mike about "campaign" mode. He wants to engage the LHA to take the
lead, which is as it should be. The city ougth to not be in a campaign but we can certainlly be
a bigger and more vocal part of an outreach effort. He said the materials will be done maybe
tomorrow. I'll get more updates later this week.
Thanks again, both of you.
ML

From: McIntyre, Lynda [mailto:mcintyl@ccf.org] On Behalf Of Meehan, Michael J., Esq.
Sent: Monday, March 30, 2015 1:04 PM
To: Butler, Kevin
Cc: Meehan, Michael J., Esq.
Subject: LHA Document (1 of 10)
 
Document 1 of 10
 
 
 
 
 
                               Lynda McIntyre |  Legal Assistant, Law Department   
                                3050 Science Park Drive, AC321  |  Beachwood, OH 44122    
                                Phone 216.448.0166 | Fax 216-448-0201 | email: mcintyl@ccf.org
 
 
 
                                                 
 
 
===================================
Please consider the environment before printing this e-mail
Cleveland Clinic is ranked as one of the top hospitals in America by U.S.News & World Report (2014). Visit us online at http://www.clevelandclinic.org for a complete listing of our services, staff and locations. Confidentiality Note: This message is intended for use only by the individual or entity to which it is addressed and may contain information that is privileged, confidential, and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient or the employee or agent responsible for delivering the message to the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution or copying of this communication is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please contact the sender immediately and destroy the material in its entirety, whether electronic or hard copy. Thank you.

The attachment Madigan March 23 2015 %22Campaign%22 mode email to Butler--B. Essi records request 03102016 (3).pdf is no longer available

LHA Cover Letter and Index (1) .pdf

(305.71 KiB) Downloaded 187 times

LHA Cover Letter and Index (1) .pdf

(305.71 KiB) Downloaded 187 times

[cmager]

Gable for Meehan (or Meehan for Gable):

We presume that the Law Director will respond to the parties who made public records requests of the City.

Surely the Law Director will respond - six months later, but only after the election!

[Bill Call]

Do laws matter anymore?

Save Lakewood Hospital was at a great disadvantage during the last campaign.

We could not use tax dollars.

We could not use Lakewood Hospital Foundation dollars.

We could not use Lakewood Hospital Association dollars.

We could not use Cleveland Clinic dollars.

We could not take advantage of low postage rates by creating a fake news paper.

Do laws matter anymore?

[Brian Essi]

Do laws matter anymore?

Save Lakewood Hospital was at a great disadvantage during the last campaign.

We could not use tax dollars.

We could not use Lakewood Hospital Foundation dollars.

We could not use Lakewood Hospital Association dollars.

We could not use Cleveland Clinic dollars.

We could not take advantage of low postage rates by creating a fake news paper.

Do laws matter anymore?

Summers admits in his deposition that LHA spent charitable public money on the campaign.


20 Did the Lakewood Hospital Association expend any
21 funds to attempt to influence the outcome of that
22 election?
23 A They did.
24 Q Okay. And how did they expend funds?
25 A They made donations to a nonprofit.
263
1 Q And what was the name of the nonprofit?
2 A I can't remember. No on 64? I can't remember the
3 name of it.
4 Q And who was the treasurer of that nonprofit?
5 A Ron Petrie.
.
14 Q What about, were you aware whether or not there
15 were advertising campaigns or public information
16 activities on the part of Lakewood Hospital Association to
17 attempt to influence the outcome of that election?
18 MS. STRATFORD: Objection.
19 A No, I think -- no, the Hospital Association did not
20 directly do that.
21 Q Okay, what about as far as direct mails to citizens
22 in Lakewood?
23 A I'm not aware of that.
24 Q Were there any authorizations that were made to
25 spend money to send mailers to Lakewood residents?
1 A Not from the Association.
2 Q Okay. Were you aware of whether or not the
3 Cleveland Clinic was spending money to affect the outcome
4 of this election?
5 A I saw some advertisements.
6 Q Okay. And that advertisement that you saw was
7 generated by the Cleveland Clinic?
8 A I presume so, yeah.
9 Q Were you aware that they were spending money, or
10 notifying residents on this matter?
11 A I was hoping they would, yeah.