Price Checking Giant Eagle

Bill Call · Post by **Bill Call** » Wed May 02, 2007 2:32 pm

I always had the impression that the prices at Giant Eagle were higher than Top's or Dave's. Since Tops and Daves were union stores it didn't seem that union wages had anything to do with the price difference.

Here are some recent comparisons:

Product Daves price Giant Eagles price
Bannanas .39lb .49lb
Romaine 1.79lb 1.99lb
Lettuce 1.49 head 1.49 head
Apples:
Granny Smith 1.39lb 1.79lb
Gala 1.39lb 1.79lb
Red Delicious 1.39lb 1.79lb
Navel oranges .40 each .69 each
Onions 3lb 1.69 bag 2.79 bag

Deli
Roast Beef 5.99 lb 7.99lb
Hard Salami 5.49 lb 5.99lb
Turkey Breast 3.99 lb 5.99lb
Virginia Ham 3.99 lb 4.99lb

I've had the produce and deli at both and the quality seems about the same.

A friend of mine (no, I am not going to give his name and address) was the manager when it was a Tops. He said a few years ago the Tops store was a cash cow. It was their most profitable store.

I wonder if the Lakewood Giant Eagle is someone's cash cow?

Lynn Farris · Post by **Lynn Farris** » Wed May 02, 2007 2:39 pm

I'm confused. Isn't Tops out of business? Where can you get TOPS prices? and where is Daves?

Great comparison list. I wonder how Heinen's stacks up against this group.

Bill Call · Post by **Bill Call** » Wed May 02, 2007 2:45 pm

Lynn Farris wrote:I'm confused. Isn't Tops out of business? Where can you get TOPS prices? and where is Daves?

Great comparison list. I wonder how Heinen's stacks up against this group.

I guess I should have used the past tense for Tops although I think they still have stores in Buffalo.

There is a very nice Dave's at East 33rd and Payne. Since I work in that area I sometimes shop there. The quality is good and the prices are competitive.

dl meckes · Post by **dl meckes** » Wed May 02, 2007 3:25 pm

Ridge and Dennison is probably the closest Dave's.

But I prefer the Rego Brother's location (and produce quality). Nothing against Dave's quality, mind you.

DougHuntingdon · Post by **DougHuntingdon** » Wed May 02, 2007 4:07 pm

well Aldi's is coming soon if they ever put anything into that big hole they dug at DeLorean, and their prices tend to be relatively low.

Bill Call · Post by **Bill Call** » Thu May 03, 2007 8:26 am

DougHuntingdon wrote:well Aldi's is coming soon if they ever put anything into that big hole they dug at DeLorean, and their prices tend to be relatively low.

The advantage of having our supermarkets owned by an out of town company is that we don't have to care whether they stay or go.

One of the conditions of the new development at Bunts and Detroit is that it NOT be a grocery store. Giant Eagle did not want any competition.

Jim O'Bryan · Post by **Jim O'Bryan** » Thu May 03, 2007 8:46 am

Bill Call wrote:One of the conditions of the new development at Bunts and Detroit is that it NOT be a grocery store. Giant Eagle did not want any competition.

Bill

How can Giant Eagle make demands on property they never owned?

Just curious.

.

Bill Call · Post by **Bill Call** » Thu May 03, 2007 8:50 am

Jim O'Bryan wrote:
Bill Call wrote:One of the conditions of the new development at Bunts and Detroit is that it NOT be a grocery store. Giant Eagle did not want any competition.

Bill

How can Giant Eagle make demands on property they never owned?

Just curious.

.

They had a lease that they would happily keep paying on to keep out the competition.

Jim O'Bryan · Post by **Jim O'Bryan** » Thu May 03, 2007 8:54 am

Bill Call wrote:
Jim O'Bryan wrote:
Bill Call wrote:One of the conditions of the new development at Bunts and Detroit is that it NOT be a grocery store. Giant Eagle did not want any competition.

Bill

How can Giant Eagle make demands on property they never owned?

Just curious.

.
They had a lease that they would happily keep paying on to keep out the competition.

oh

.

Justine Cooper · Post by **Justine Cooper** » Thu May 03, 2007 8:32 pm

I usually shop at Marcs but went to Giant Eagle last week, and although it was a nice experience, a bag of string cheese I bought had a date of 2006!!!!!! and spring!!!!

Beajay Michaud · Post by **Beajay Michaud** » Fri May 04, 2007 12:53 pm

I hate Giant Eagle in Lakewood, it is too crowded. Certain days of the week the selves are kind of bare. The prices are higher than at the Giant Eagle in Rocky River on some items. I try to only purchase there if I don't have time to go anywhere else. I usally shop at Costco, West Market and Marc's in Rocky River.

Bea

Bryan Schwegler · Post by **Bryan Schwegler** » Fri May 04, 2007 1:31 pm

I usually either shop at Heinen's or Costco for bulk stuff. I agree, the Giant Eagle is just too crowded and I don't like the people that work there.

I'd rather go to Rocky River and spend my money at a locally own grocery chain than stay in Lakewood and pay an out of state company just their employees can act like they're rather light themselves on fire than smile or help someone.

Beajay Michaud · Post by **Beajay Michaud** » Fri May 04, 2007 4:08 pm

I've never been in an Aldi's. I guess I wil have to check them out.

Justine Cooper · Post by **Justine Cooper** » Sat May 05, 2007 4:29 pm

Aldi's is great with prices but no fresh meat. Nature's Bin is the best for fresh and healthy food. If you can find someone to split the $50 membership at Costco's in Avon, they have some good deals and have an extremely well run business. The best ethics and treatment of employees that I have heard, as well as exceptional return policies.

David Lay · Post by **David Lay** » Sat May 05, 2007 5:00 pm

Costco is fantastic. Jennie has a membership, and we always shop there whenever she's home from med school.

Price Checking Giant Eagle

Price Checking Giant Eagle

Daves

Store

Re: Store

Re: Store

Re: Store