Re-Imagining Lakewood Park as Mixed-Use Development/Marina - 2006

The jumping off discussion area for the rest of the Deck. All things Lakewood.
Please check out our other sections. As we refile many discussions from the past into
their proper sections please check them out and offer suggestions.

Moderator: Jim O'Bryan

User avatar
Jim O'Bryan
Posts: 14196
Joined: Thu Mar 10, 2005 10:12 pm
Location: Lakewood
Contact:

Re-Imagining Lakewood Park as Mixed-Use Development/Marina - 2006

Post by Jim O'Bryan »

Image

Brian Essi posted "Re-Imagining Lakewood Park as Mixed-Use Development/Marina" and came up with his dream for the Lakewood Park area, and his effort to dream big. What Brian did not realize is that a longtime Lakewood residents, student, artists, and now architect and city planner took a crack at it in 2006. Well actually it was back in 2004 when young Savannah Farris sat down and started to work on her thesis and final project for Cleveland Institute of Art. Her dream, and the dream of many was so complete, so encompassing, and so well thought out, most of us could not believe that it was not given time by the City of Lakewood. Not only did it recreate some of Lakewood's most valuable and versatile space, it created high end housing, shopping, and finally a beach for residents to use.

I post the boards and the text here, you tell me, would Lakewood have been better? The same year Savannah presented this, and in the years after, we spent $10,000 to study chickens, pit bulls, boutique hotels in run down empty Lakewood offices, re centers, education and what to do and not do with Kauffman Park. BUT NOT ONE PENNY WAS SPENT BY CIVIC LEADERS ON A PLAN THAT WOULD PUSH LAKEWOOD INTO FINANCIAL SECURITY FOR DECADES.

The Army Corp of Engineers would have underwritten more than 1/2 the study, and 2/3rds of the building of it.

I present, Savannah's Peninsula.

Image

Savannah Farris, a 2001 graduate of Lakewood High School and 5th year student at the Cleveland Institute of Art, has proposed in her thesis a redesign of Lakewood Park as well as a 26 acre peninsula designed to stimulate the economy and bring activity down to the water.

Savannah states “I grew up in Lakewood and because of that I wanted to do a project for the city, because I love the city and believe it has so much potential for growth.” Savannah indicates that when she began the thesis project, she did some informal surveys of Lakewood residents to see what they thought was Lakewood’s greatest assets and what it was lacking. Overwhelmingly the location was one of Lakewood’s greatest assets especially that it was a city on Lake Erie. Savannah reports that many people saw the lakefront as a great opportunity for the city of Lakewood to capitalize on its location. Many people also loved that Lakewood was a walking city and that was clean and safe. Others commented that it was a neo-urbanist environment with a generally progressive population. However, when discussing the problems facing Lakewood, the economy was clearly the issue, whether the discussion was high taxes, the need for more business, or flight to the outer ring suburbs.

So Savannah decided that it made sense to focus on the Lakefront and Lakewood Park a 33 acre park which is already serving as the de-facto town square, at least in the summer months. Savannah states “I spent most of my summers growing up at Lakewood Park, taking swim lessons, taking tennis lessons and then joining the swim team and swimming and watching the sun rise every morning while I swam in the summer. I also enjoyed the playground. As an adult though, I started to see that the park while good, could be so much more. But I was acutely aware that the city’s budget was tight and any plan to enhance Lakewood Park must be accompanied by revenue enhancing proposals. I saw Lakewood Park as a great place to grow, especially growth in community, learning about and being closer to nature and the environment, entertainment, and a way to boost the economy of Lakewood.”

Savannah lays out the plan for the new Lakewood Park and Peninsula. She changed many things, but thought that it was important to keep the large green expanse on the east side and the activities on the west side. She reorganized the way in which you enter the park and now it has a formal, but inviting entrance. As you can see from the existing plan, the entrance was a bit confusing before and the parking didn’t make much sense. Generally, the plan groups similar activities and create synergy. Another major change was moving the stage from the middle of the green way to a central location with views of the Lake allow music to waft over the entire park. The new amphitheatre will be designed to hold full theatrical productions and musical productions. There is also a learning lab that allows hands on activities dealing with nature, the environment and energy issues. The utilization of the center island as the marketplace enhances the location and accessibility of revenue producing activities like the Farmers Market, which should be moved to Saturday morning at this location so that more participation is possible. Additionally this market can be used by various groups for such things as antique fairs, holiday fairs, and craft shows.

To assist in the revenue enhancing side, a 26 acre peninsula that features approximately 140 buildings made up of restaurants, retail stores and homes was designed. A 124 dock marina is featured with both permanent docks as well as temporary docks for people who want to stop and visit the peninsula and Lakewood Park for the day. The creation of the peninsula also allows the creation of a real beach. A wind mill farm that could cleanly generate the power for Lakewood and produce enough energy to sell other cities was recommended as well as our own water intake to provide Lakewood with fresh water and allow us to compete with Cleveland for the sale of water to other municipalities.

The redesign of Lakewood Park will also make Lakewood a more attractive place to live, which will assist in attracting new residents and will aid in the revenue stream to keep existing citizens.


Image

This is the text on the boards:

Opportunities for Gathering at Lakewood Park are improved by:
Redesign layout of the park to group similar activities and create more pockets for gathering.
Redesign of the Women’s Pavilion to add a deck and fire pits outside for more use in the winter.
Redesign of the Kiwanis Outdoor Pavilion to make it more attractive and rearrangement and addition of picnic tables throughout the park.
Redesign and enlargement of the swimming pool deck to accommodate more seating and lounge chairs for sunning as well as adding some shady areas for people who have had too much sun.
Rest pockets featuring vertical gardens with seating.
Sculpture areas where either permanent sculptures can be located or traveling outdoor displays of outdoor sculpture can be exhibited for a period of time which should provide opportunities for artist talks.
Along the multi-use path place LED lights which will charge during the day and provide lighting for evening strolls making the park friendlier at night.
Places to sit in the community market and rest and talk with friends.
Now there are several places for groups of all sizes which are more defined.


Opportunities for Learning at Lakewood Park are improved by:
Relocating the Historic Old Stone House to a central location for better inclusion in park activities.
Relocating the Veterans Memorial to a central location for better visibility and larger memorial services.
Construction of a Learning Lab for the public to learn more about the environment and for teachers to conduct science classes. The Lab would be designed to conduct experiments and have hands on activities and displays. The lab will be surfaced with photovoltaics (PV solar panels) to create a great leaning opportunity for both children and adults about renewable energy. The Learning Lab is pictured above with children playing with a solar bag which teaches them about solar energy.
Incorporation of a Wind Farm off the coast of Lakewood Park to generate electricity for Lakewood. This is an opportunity for Lakewood to not only make a giant step toward improving the environment but additionally increase revenues by reducing the cost of energy. Several of the displays in the learning lab can be dedicated to how wind mills generate energy
Informal satellite learning lab on the beach for other activities and experiments.
Labeled plants and trees throughout the park. to foster greater awareness of nature
Displays in lighthouses regarding various information.
Walks conducted by citizens on different subjects.
More classes offered at Lakewood Park by Recreational office especially including sport instruction. Currently the swimming lessons offered at Lakewoood Park are very popular.


Opportunities for Playing at Lakewood Park are improved by:
The addition of activities such as bocci ball, chess and checker tables, shuffleboard courts, badminton courts, croquet, and lawn bowling. This allows adults to play and interact with each other and their children or grandchildren.
Addition to the Concession Stand to accommodate renting out of equipment necessary for various activities.
Addition to the extremely successful and highly popular Skatepark. The addition allows for skateboarders, bikers and rollerbladers to play in different areas.
Addition of two full size basketball courts.
Relocation of stage and additional features to make the stage a full amphitheatre where events can vary from movie screening to concerts and theater. Events could be free of charge to all or the seating can be charged.
More Winter Activities including a Winter Carnival.
The New Peninsula into Lake Erie. This affords many things:
A beach and access to the water! Floating islands are in the water for people to swim out to and rest.
A marina with a boat launch and docks. The marina also offers rentals in kayaks, windsurfing boards, small sailboats and motor boats as well as water tours and parasailing.
A new water playground where children can safely play with shooting water. Near the water playground is stairs into the lake with a flowform( pictured below) for more timid water participants.
More green spaces and lookout points for various activities.

Opportunities for Prospering at Lakewood Park are improved by:
The addition of a 26 acre peninsula built on reclaimed land. Features:
A full service marina with rental space for docks as well as temporary docking for visitors to Lakewood Park.
Mixed use buildings with retail, restaurants and residences.. This brings not only increased income tax to the city, but property tax as well. Additionally the county benefits by the increase in sales tax revenues.
Two amazing lookout points one of the downtown Cleveland skyline and one for the setting sun.
Modern lighthouses powered by the wind farm provide Lakewood with a trademark symbol that will be capable of being viewed from downtown the water or from shore.
Lots of green space and surrounding boardwalk.
Protection of the land from erosion and allows for a beach.
Implementing a wind farm off the coast of Lakewood Park which would be capable of generating energy for Lakewood and potentially for sale to neighboring municipalities.
The incorporation of alternative sustainable energy sources used in the learning lab and windmill farms, should establish Lakewood as a forward thinking community ripe for innovative businesses.
Implementation of a fresh water intake to provide Lakewood our own fresh water and to allow us to compete with the City of Cleveland for sale of water to other municipalities.
The utilization of the center island as the marketplace enhances the location and accessibility of revenue producing activities like the Farmers Market, which should be moved to Saturday morning at this location so that more participation is possible. Additionally this market can be used by various groups for such things as antique fairs, holiday fairs, and craft shows.
The redesign of Lakewood Park will also make Lakewood a more attractive place to live, which will assist in attracting new residents and will aid in the revenue stream to keep existing citizens.

Key for Plan

Location Markers
1 Lake Rd.
2 Belle Ave.
3 Lake Erie
4 Parking

Gathering Areas
5 Women’s Pavilion
6 Rest Pockets
7 Foster Pool Bathhouse
8 Kiwanis‘ Open Air Pavilion
9 Market Seating

Learning Areas
10 Learning Lab
11 Old Stone House
12 Veterans’ Memorial
13 Satellite Beach Learning Lab
14 Lighthouse


Playing Areas
15 Skatepark
16 Bikepark
17 Rollerbadepark
18 Amphitheatre
19 Chess and Checkers Tables
20 Lakewood Public Beach
21 Waterpark
22 Croquet
23 Shuffleboard
24 Badminton
25 Lawn Bowling
26 Bocci Ball
27 Foster Pool
28 Four Square
29 Multipurpose Playing Fields
30 Kids Cove Playground
31 Baseball
32 Basket ball
33 Tennis

Prosperous Areas
34 Mixed Use Buildings (Restaurants, Retail & Residences)
35 Market
36 Concessions (New Plan is Expanded to include equipment Rental)
37 Boat Launch & Trailer Parking
38 Windfarm & Water Intake Crib
39 Docks and Marina

Image

Image

But instead of this project which was a bit to NIMBY for civic leaders, we cheered the arrival of 5 Guys, Detroiter, University of Akron, and other illusions.

.
Jim O'Bryan
Lakewood Resident

"The very act of observing disturbs the system."
Werner Heisenberg

"If anything I've said seems useful to you, I'm glad.
If not, don't worry. Just forget about it."
His Holiness The Dalai Lama
mjkuhns
Posts: 608
Joined: Mon Aug 15, 2016 8:43 am
Contact:

Re: Re-Imagining Lakewood Park as Mixed-Use Development/Marina - 2006

Post by mjkuhns »

Fascinating; thank you for posting.

I can only add that perhaps a NIMBY factor was (and is) complemented by an NIH factor.
‘Not-Invented-Here (NIH) Syndrome’ refers to a corporate or business culture that prevents buying, using or copying (and sometimes even learning) from others in the same business domain/field. An external idea or solution is rejected because it was not developed in-house…

The unwillingness or total rejection to use an idea or product because it originates from another culture is also seen as a form of nationalism (where any thing Not-Invented-Here is not as good as ours and the thinking goes that if if the idea was good enough we would have already thought of them) …
http://www.casestudyinc.com/glossary/no ... e-syndrome
:: matt kuhns ::
User avatar
Jim O'Bryan
Posts: 14196
Joined: Thu Mar 10, 2005 10:12 pm
Location: Lakewood
Contact:

Re: Re-Imagining Lakewood Park as Mixed-Use Development/Marina - 2006

Post by Jim O'Bryan »

mjkuhns wrote:Fascinating; thank you for posting.

I can only add that perhaps a NIMBY factor was (and is) complemented by an NIH factor.
‘Not-Invented-Here (NIH) Syndrome’ refers to a corporate or business culture that prevents buying, using or copying (and sometimes even learning) from others in the same business domain/field. An external idea or solution is rejected because it was not developed in-house…

The unwillingness or total rejection to use an idea or product because it originates from another culture is also seen as a form of nationalism (where any thing Not-Invented-Here is not as good as ours and the thinking goes that if if the idea was good enough we would have already thought of them) …
http://www.casestudyinc.com/glossary/no ... e-syndrome

MJK


And to add to it her parents fought the secret government on the lies and misinformation at the West End Strip Mall Project.

The same people fought to ignore this, just like they fought to get the money from the sale of the hospital for their own plans.

City has been broken for a long time.

This group of thieves and clowns ask Lakewoodites to "Dream Big," they have proven time and time again, they can't handle it.

.
Jim O'Bryan
Lakewood Resident

"The very act of observing disturbs the system."
Werner Heisenberg

"If anything I've said seems useful to you, I'm glad.
If not, don't worry. Just forget about it."
His Holiness The Dalai Lama
Mark Kindt
Posts: 2644
Joined: Sat Dec 03, 2016 11:06 am

Re: Re-Imagining Lakewood Park as Mixed-Use Development/Marina - 2006

Post by Mark Kindt »

Brilliant! Visionary! This needs to be accomplished!
User avatar
Jim O'Bryan
Posts: 14196
Joined: Thu Mar 10, 2005 10:12 pm
Location: Lakewood
Contact:

Re: Re-Imagining Lakewood Park as Mixed-Use Development/Marina - 2006

Post by Jim O'Bryan »

Mark Kindt wrote:Brilliant! Visionary! This needs to be accomplished!

Mark

What truly amazes me is that this vision, was reaching out to everyone, and delivering the goods.
There were 6 full notebooks of information, studies, financial, etc. that went with this presentation.
It nearly funded itself, at every stage, even in the initial study, the city refused to do. They gave it 5 minutes during a council meeting.
What would the valued of $50 million in new taxable property coming online, just as we sold off our largest employer?
Five to seven years to fill area two years for it to settle, then commence building.
$50 million in Lakewood property dollars back then are more than $100 million today.

Instead look at the plans Lakewood has put forward to Detroit, Kauffman, Lakewood Hospital are like kids drawings and ideas compared to what is presented here and why.

This is what worries me most about City Hall and civic leaders, they always show up incredibly light to the party.

Peninsula, or "DowntowN Logo"? The study for peninsula was $70,000 less than the study for "Dowtown Signage."

Some of the same people telling us how great the hospital deal is made that decision too.

.
Jim O'Bryan
Lakewood Resident

"The very act of observing disturbs the system."
Werner Heisenberg

"If anything I've said seems useful to you, I'm glad.
If not, don't worry. Just forget about it."
His Holiness The Dalai Lama
Mark Kindt
Posts: 2644
Joined: Sat Dec 03, 2016 11:06 am

Re: Re-Imagining Lakewood Park as Mixed-Use Development/Marina - 2006

Post by Mark Kindt »

Thank you for this additional background. No wonder that as a long-time resident I was completely unaware that a proposal of this magnitude was on the drawing board.
bentleymike
Posts: 107
Joined: Tue Aug 30, 2016 11:20 am
Contact:

Re: Re-Imagining Lakewood Park as Mixed-Use Development/Marina - 2006

Post by bentleymike »

I know Savannah very well. I think a good chunk of this plan could still be implemented at Lakewood Park. If not used there, then we should consider some of these throughout the city's parks. Moving the stage down near the water (I'm thinking on the side where you see downtown) would be amazing.
Mike Bentley
Marguerite Harkness
Posts: 293
Joined: Thu May 14, 2015 10:42 am

Re: Re-Imagining Lakewood Park as Mixed-Use Development/Marina - 2006

Post by Marguerite Harkness »

This is a fabulous redesign. I had no idea this plan existed. Thoughtful, intelligent, well-designed, purposeful, and with suggested funding to implement.
User avatar
Jim O'Bryan
Posts: 14196
Joined: Thu Mar 10, 2005 10:12 pm
Location: Lakewood
Contact:

Re: Re-Imagining Lakewood Park as Mixed-Use Development/Marina - 2006

Post by Jim O'Bryan »

bentleymike wrote:I know Savannah very well. I think a good chunk of this plan could still be implemented at Lakewood Park. If not used there, then we should consider some of these throughout the city's parks. Moving the stage down near the water (I'm thinking on the side where you see downtown) would be amazing.

Mike

You need to understand so many things about this project. Most importantly, do it without the peninsula, you are wasting money.

The peninsula, pays for everything and creates serious taxes, jobs, and opportunity.

The City has tried to cherry pick these ideas, and as usual they come up way short, and lacking any real vision.

Solstice Steps $2.5 million in concrete, or the natural amphitheater with the lake and city of Cleveland as a back drop.

Solstice Steps a twice borrowed idea, rushed through to cover up the hospital. Meanwhile the pool less than 200 yards away needs $2.5 million in repairs.

For six months this set up and all the notebooks were in the office, many came through, no one saw a problem or a negative. Well one, Bob Stark wanted it twice as big, and he would have bought in heavily.

.
Jim O'Bryan
Lakewood Resident

"The very act of observing disturbs the system."
Werner Heisenberg

"If anything I've said seems useful to you, I'm glad.
If not, don't worry. Just forget about it."
His Holiness The Dalai Lama
Stan Austin
Contributor
Posts: 2465
Joined: Tue Mar 15, 2005 12:02 pm
Contact:

Re: Re-Imagining Lakewood Park as Mixed-Use Development/Marina - 2006

Post by Stan Austin »

A worthwhile reminder--- when Savannah Farris wrote this I think she was a senior (20-21yrs old) at the Cleveland Institute of Art.
Lori Allen _
Posts: 2550
Joined: Wed Jan 28, 2015 2:37 pm

Re: Re-Imagining Lakewood Park as Mixed-Use Development/Marina - 2006

Post by Lori Allen _ »

What a talented young lady. It is too bad that she is not Mayor right now. There is no money left for anything. Perhaps Summers or one of his many mouth pieces would like to post and show where all our city finances went.
cameron karslake
Posts: 646
Joined: Thu Apr 23, 2015 8:35 am

Re: Re-Imagining Lakewood Park as Mixed-Use Development/Marina - 2006

Post by cameron karslake »

I remember this proposal back in the day. Being a lake lover, I thought is was amazing. I had no idea it was an art students (visionary!) vision. Incredible!

Thank you for posting it again, together with all the accompanying boards of other options etc. Reading it again, now, makes me yearn for people who really know how to "Dream Big"!

That the city only gave this proposal 5 minutes is a crime and insulting.
mjkuhns
Posts: 608
Joined: Mon Aug 15, 2016 8:43 am
Contact:

Re: Re-Imagining Lakewood Park as Mixed-Use Development/Marina - 2006

Post by mjkuhns »

Only a side note, but possibly of some small interest…

In reading about this, I have been reminded of a scene from Robert Graves' fictionalized life of the Emperor Claudius.

Claudius tasks his government's engineers with drafting plans for a large public works project. They do, but also estimate that it will take a decade and be almost prohibitively expensive.

Claudius, a historian before his unexpected elevation to head of state, responds by going into the archives. He discovers almost identical plans commissioned nine decades earlier by Julius Caesar; though never executed, the estimate by Caesar's team forecast half the time that Claudius's engineers claimed would be required. The old estimate of the cost was less than half, even allowing for inflation.

Having the advantage of being emperor, Claudius uses this evidence of sham estimating to pressure his engineers into building the project efficiently and affordably.

While this doesn't have any direct impact on our affairs, I have been amused by the parallel of good ideas going into the file cabinet, where they nonetheless remain good ideas, and enlightening to any who can bother to look. Claudius's project was, in fact, a harbor…

Ms. Farris's project has only languished for a decade, meanwhile. Just perhaps some greater interest in outside ideas, and greater initiative, can be summoned up in Lakewood before a whole 90 years go by.

(The scene I reference appears in chapter 11 of Claudius the God. And in the televised adaptation I, Claudius, probably episode 11 "Fool's Luck.")
:: matt kuhns ::
cmager
Posts: 696
Joined: Fri Feb 19, 2016 8:33 am

Re: Re-Imagining Lakewood Park as Mixed-Use Development/Marina - 2006

Post by cmager »

mjkuhns wrote:Only a side note, but possibly of some small interest…

In reading about this, I have been reminded of a scene from Robert Graves' fictionalized life of the Emperor Claudius.

Claudius tasks his government's engineers with drafting plans for a large public works project. They do, but also estimate that it will take a decade and be almost prohibitively expensive.

Claudius, a historian before his unexpected elevation to head of state, responds by going into the archives. He discovers almost identical plans commissioned nine decades earlier by Julius Caesar; though never executed, the estimate by Caesar's team forecast half the time that Claudius's engineers claimed would be required. The old estimate of the cost was less than half, even allowing for inflation.

Having the advantage of being emperor, Claudius uses this evidence of sham estimating to pressure his engineers into building the project efficiently and affordably.

While this doesn't have any direct impact on our affairs, I have been amused by the parallel of good ideas going into the file cabinet, where they nonetheless remain good ideas, and enlightening to any who can bother to look. Claudius's project was, in fact, a harbor…

Ms. Farris's project has only languished for a decade, meanwhile. Just perhaps some greater interest in outside ideas, and greater initiative, can be summoned up in Lakewood before a whole 90 years go by.

(The scene I reference appears in chapter 11 of Claudius the God. And in the televised adaptation I, Claudius, probably episode 11 "Fool's Luck.")
This! The Deck makes this possible. I love the Deck!
User avatar
Jim O'Bryan
Posts: 14196
Joined: Thu Mar 10, 2005 10:12 pm
Location: Lakewood
Contact:

Re: Re-Imagining Lakewood Park as Mixed-Use Development/Marina - 2006

Post by Jim O'Bryan »

As we wait for the run down from Lakewood's Park lakefront plan. Let's take one more look at the work of at the time a young college student who did her own two year study on the park, how it was used, and what the city of Lakewood needed.

She drew up as her graduation thesis what has become known as the Savannah's Peninsula.

When launched, the only people that thought it wouldn't work was a handful of Lakewood's power brokers, that had been defeated in their attempt to turn the westside of Lakewood, well everything west of West Clifton into a strip mall. There plan for the West End Strip Mall was not only uninspiring it was filled with miss-truths and little buy in. Not surprising, this group would later work together to close and sell of Lakewood Hospital into a private fund they manage.

Meanwhile the Lakewood Observer had this on display for two months, the only negative comments I heard, was that her parents had stop the strip mall being built at the end of Detroit. Bob Stark the Crocker Park developer came through, and LOVED IT. Said he would be willing to buy in, if the peninsula would be bigger. The plan creates a peninsula to pay for the park and create another $550 million in taxable business and property. Think about it.

So as the city debated the size and how much we have to pay for a fishing pier, let's look at something Amazing.

.
Jim O'Bryan
Lakewood Resident

"The very act of observing disturbs the system."
Werner Heisenberg

"If anything I've said seems useful to you, I'm glad.
If not, don't worry. Just forget about it."
His Holiness The Dalai Lama
Post Reply