It's Over Now, Dead And Gone...A Hospital Commentary And Reflection...

The jumping off discussion area for the rest of the Deck. All things Lakewood.
Please check out our other sections. As we refile many discussions from the past into
their proper sections please check them out and offer suggestions.

Moderator: Jim O'Bryan

Gary Rice
Posts: 1651
Joined: Wed Aug 23, 2006 9:59 pm
Location: Lakewood

It's Over Now, Dead And Gone...A Hospital Commentary And Reflection...

Post by Gary Rice »

For all you well-meaning do-ers, dreamers, doubters, and 'Deckers...

Just letting you know. It's over now. Dead and gone.

Funeral services have yet to be announced.

I'm referring to the once and honorable fight to save our hospital from the wrecking ball.

I can also tell you the exact moment that the nails were finally driven into the hospital's coffin. I was there. It was right after the Mayor's State of the City address last night, when the applause erupted. Virtually everyone was there too, from the Lakewood School Board, to City Council, to many interested salt-of-the-earth Lakewoodites...we who were there all witnessed it.

Being a musical entertainer, back in the day, I've always been very sensitive to the meaning behind applause. There's polite applause, such as you might hear when a young violin student squeaks her way through her first recital. Then, there's "glad it's over" applause, that you might hear when some boring long-winded speaker finally finishes...

...and then you have the applause that we heard last night.

It was full-blown, utterly enthusiastic, virtually unanimous rock-star-like applause for the mayor, and while it was not accompanied by screaming, shouts, or the like, it was nonetheless long lasting, enthusiastic, and very sincere. In no uncertain terms, it was letting those of us who have marched and supported saving our hospital know that our dream was finally over.

I personally did everything in my power to try to be an active part in saving Lakewood Hospital. I wrote columns about saving our hospital, I marched in the streets for nearly a mile on my unsteady crooked legs with hundreds of hospital supporters, while playing my banjo with the Dixieland band that accompanied the group...In short, I was utterly opposed to losing what was arguably one of our community's finest assets. I know full well that the loss of this hospital could well mean the loss of some lives too, and for that reason alone, I was absolutely driven to try to save it. My mother had died there. My dad's and my own lives were both saved there. My grandmother fought her long and losing battle with a dreaded illness there, and countless other times, my family and friends have gone there to get patched up for one thing or another. Emotionally, that hospital has been a big part of my life, and I would suspect, many of yours, as well.

Every day of our lives, things and people die, and things and people are born. That's just the way it goes. We rejoice in births and lament deaths. Both are complex events, and yet, utterly simple in their nature. Lately, however, there are many who prefer to celebrate the life of the deceased, rather than mourn. Perhaps that's just another way to deal with loss, I don't know. What I do know is that the loss of something or someone hurts very badly. It tears at the very fiber of our beings. It goes so counter to our American live-forever culture that values acquisition so much, and loss, so little. Yet there it is....loss....death....as perpetual as the falling of leaves, and as much a part of our lives, as gain and birth are.

While there will, no doubt, be many here who will continue, (perhaps like some Confederate revisionists) to want to hold onto the past, (and yes, the past can be a wonderful place to visit) the simple fact of the matter is that we cannot live in the past. You cannot live with people or things no longer with us. That's just not the way things work. It is for the living that we must live.

I am related to a platoon or more of Mom's ancestors who fought under the flag of the Confederacy. In my heart of hearts, I honor their memory, and I think about the Stars and Bars that was sometimes etched into their gravestones. At the same time, I have seen the gravestones of my father's ancestors who fought with the Grand Army of the Republic, and I've seen and placed the little American flags on their graves. Heroes all.

At the 50th anniversary of the Battle of Gettysburg, many of those still-living ancestors of yours and mine again met on that field, only this time, for pot-luck dinners, cane-assisted walks together up the side of Little Round Top, and for sharing the bond that only brothers who have borne the battle can do. See, soldiers care little about the bigger issues of such a war. Slavery? States' Rights? Naw, all they cared about back then was the person standing next to them.

The Stars and Bars and the Rebel Yell were seen and heard again on that day, as were the colors and calls of the Union Forces. On that day however, the Stars and Bars flew together with Stars and Stripes. Grown men cried like babies, and the healing began over fried chicken.

Our century-old hospital is finished. Those of us who fought for her are tired, perhaps bitter, and perhaps at times disillusioned. Many of us may still cling to the hope of a last minute reprieve, either through the ballot box or the courts. Political opportunists and conspiracy theorists will no doubt continue to use our Dear Old Lady for whatever ends they can think of, but in the end, it's just time for us to let her go.

Let's face it, miles of rotting wiring, leaky corroded lead pipes, asbestos-laden plaster and insulation, lead paint, and other out-dated building materials that seemed to make sense a hundred years ago have no place in a modern medical center. Indeed, even though much of the above was likely either abated, or painted over, or whatever, during the numerous remodeling efforts that have transpired over the years, you can only try to make a silk purse out of a sow's ear so many times. Eventually, there's just nothing left to stitch to.

For those who remember, there was great controversy and emotion as well, when we began to tear down those old school buildings that were also once so much a part and parcel of the pulse of our city. Lincoln, Madison, the old Harding, the high school.....all of those met the wrecking ball, and our children are (or soon will be) in much more modern up-to-date facilities with much safer electricity, water, heat, and lighting.

For that matter, (as even those who advocated for saving our hospital would freely admit) the medical facilities that we have close by to us are either beautifully new, or have been nicely updated, and that is a blessing, at least.

Last night, Mayor Michael P. Summers laid out the rationale for his decision to be proactive regarding the Lakewood Hospital Crisis. That his decision was widely approved of by community leaders was patently obvious. Whether it was the "right" decision or not will be a subjective call for history to answer, but one thing was quite certain in my mind as I reflected on the minutes-long applause. The fight for Lakewood Hospital... was over.

Perhaps one day soon, we can all gather together for a pot-luck dinner down by the Solstice Steps. If the soldiers at Gettysburg were able to put aside their differences, so too can we all. All of us on all sides of this issue, engaged in the good fight. Perhaps one day soon, we can all begin to engage in the good peace.

All, just my opinion here, and I may be wrong...but...

Back to the banjo... :D
james fitzgibbons
Posts: 412
Joined: Sun Jan 31, 2016 3:34 pm

Re: It's Over Now, Dead And Gone...A Hospital Commentary And Reflection...

Post by james fitzgibbons »

Gary Rice wrote:For all you well-meaning do-ers, dreamers, doubters, and 'Deckers...

Just letting you know. It's over now. Dead and gone.

Funeral services have yet to be announced.

I'm referring to the once and honorable fight to save our hospital from the wrecking ball.

I can also tell you the exact moment that the nails were finally driven into the hospital's coffin. I was there. It was right after the Mayor's State of the City address last night, when the applause erupted. Virtually everyone was there too, from the Lakewood School Board, to City Council, to many interested salt-of-the-earth Lakewoodites...we who were there all witnessed it.

Being a musical entertainer, back in the day, I've always been very sensitive to the meaning behind applause. There's polite applause, such as you might hear when a young violin student squeaks her way through her first recital. Then, there's "glad it's over" applause, that you might hear when some boring long-winded speaker finally finishes...

...and then you have the applause that we heard last night.

It was full-blown, utterly enthusiastic, virtually unanimous rock-star-like applause for the mayor, and while it was not accompanied by screaming, shouts, or the like, it was nonetheless long lasting, enthusiastic, and very sincere. In no uncertain terms, it was letting those of us who have marched and supported saving our hospital know that our dream was finally over.

I personally did everything in my power to try to be an active part in saving Lakewood Hospital. I wrote columns about saving our hospital, I marched in the streets for nearly a mile on my unsteady crooked legs with hundreds of hospital supporters, while playing my banjo with the Dixieland band that accompanied the group...In short, I was utterly opposed to losing what was arguably one of our community's finest assets. I know full well that the loss of this hospital could well mean the loss of some lives too, and for that reason alone, I was absolutely driven to try to save it. My mother had died there. My dad's and my own lives were both saved there. My grandmother fought her long and losing battle with a dreaded illness there, and countless other times, my family and friends have gone there to get patched up for one thing or another. Emotionally, that hospital has been a big part of my life, and I would suspect, many of yours, as well.

Every day of our lives, things and people die, and things and people are born. That's just the way it goes. We rejoice in births and lament deaths. Both are complex events, and yet, utterly simple in their nature. Lately, however, there are many who prefer to celebrate the life of the deceased, rather than mourn. Perhaps that's just another way to deal with loss, I don't know. What I do know is that the loss of something or someone hurts very badly. It tears at the very fiber of our beings. It goes so counter to our American live-forever culture that values acquisition so much, and loss, so little. Yet there it is....loss....death....as perpetual as the falling of leaves, and as much a part of our lives, as gain and birth are.

While there will, no doubt, be many here who will continue, (perhaps like some Confederate revisionists) to want to hold onto the past, (and yes, the past can be a wonderful place to visit) the simple fact of the matter is that we cannot live in the past. You cannot live with people or things no longer with us. That's just not the way things work. It is for the living that we must live.

I am related to a platoon or more of Mom's ancestors who fought under the flag of the Confederacy. In my heart of hearts, I honor their memory, and I think about the Stars and Bars that was sometimes etched into their gravestones. At the same time, I have seen the gravestones of my father's ancestors who fought with the Grand Army of the Republic, and I've seen and placed the little American flags on their graves. Heroes all.

At the 50th anniversary of the Battle of Gettysburg, many of those still-living ancestors of yours and mine again met on that field, only this time, for pot-luck dinners, cane-assisted walks together up the side of Little Round Top, and for sharing the bond that only brothers who have borne the battle can do. See, soldiers care little about the bigger issues of such a war. Slavery? States' Rights? Naw, all they cared about back then was the person standing next to them.

The Stars and Bars and the Rebel Yell were seen and heard again on that day, as were the colors and calls of the Union Forces. On that day however, the Stars and Bars flew together with Stars and Stripes. Grown men cried like babies, and the healing began over fried chicken.

Our century-old hospital is finished. Those of us who fought for her are tired, perhaps bitter, and perhaps at times disillusioned. Many of us may still cling to the hope of a last minute reprieve, either through the ballot box or the courts. Political opportunists and conspiracy theorists will no doubt continue to use our Dear Old Lady for whatever ends they can think of, but in the end, it's just time for us to let her go.

Let's face it, miles of rotting wiring, leaky corroded lead pipes, asbestos-laden plaster and insulation, lead paint, and other out-dated building materials that seemed to make sense a hundred years ago have no place in a modern medical center. Indeed, even though much of the above was likely either abated, or painted over, or whatever, during the numerous remodeling efforts that have transpired over the years, you can only try to make a silk purse out of a sow's ear so many times. Eventually, there's just nothing left to stitch to.

For those who remember, there was great controversy and emotion as well, when we began to tear down those old school buildings that were also once so much a part and parcel of the pulse of our city. Lincoln, Madison, the old Harding, the high school.....all of those met the wrecking ball, and our children are (or soon will be) in much more modern up-to-date facilities with much safer electricity, water, heat, and lighting.

For that matter, (as even those who advocated for saving our hospital would freely admit) the medical facilities that we have close by to us are either beautifully new, or have been nicely updated, and that is a blessing, at least.

Last night, Mayor Michael P. Summers laid out the rationale for his decision to be proactive regarding the Lakewood Hospital Crisis. That his decision was widely approved of by community leaders was patently obvious. Whether it was the "right" decision or not will be a subjective call for history to answer, but one thing was quite certain in my mind as I reflected on the minutes-long applause. The fight for Lakewood Hospital... was over.

Perhaps one day soon, we can all gather together for a pot-luck dinner down by the Solstice Steps. If the soldiers at Gettysburg were able to put aside their differences, so too can we all. All of us on all sides of this issue, engaged in the good fight. Perhaps one day soon, we can all begin to engage in the good peace.

All, just my opinion here, and I may be wrong...but...

Back to the banjo... :D
You have wasted your time putting all of your words on this site. You are a schill for the Mayor. What a bunch of crap, it is sickening dialog.
Gary Rice
Posts: 1651
Joined: Wed Aug 23, 2006 9:59 pm
Location: Lakewood

Re: It's Over Now, Dead And Gone...A Hospital Commentary And Reflection...

Post by Gary Rice »

Mr. Fitzgibbons:

As I said, I may indeed have arrived at opinions and conclusions that may be wrong sir, but I have no intentions of representing the Mayor's or any others opinions other than my own.

Respectfully,

Gary
Brian Essi
Posts: 2421
Joined: Thu May 07, 2015 11:46 am

Re: It's Over Now, Dead And Gone...A Hospital Commentary And Reflection...

Post by Brian Essi »

I don't think Mr. Rice is a shill--he plays the role of peacemaker.

His effort above will fail to achieve peace, because City Hall has declared a war on its people and has no interest in peace.

You cannot have peace without justice.

You cannot have justice without embracing the truth.

What is clear is that The truth is a foreigner at City Hall.

Laws have been violated and lies have been told--ccintinuing last night.

You cannot attain peace and justice by arguing the ends justify the means or even the other way around.

We are still in the first quarter of the war.

It is not over and the outcome remains uncertain.

SLH is defending the truth. City Hall runs from it.
David Anderson has no legitimate answers
cameron karslake
Posts: 646
Joined: Thu Apr 23, 2015 8:35 am

Re: It's Over Now, Dead And Gone...A Hospital Commentary And Reflection...

Post by cameron karslake »

Gary Rice wrote:
"Last night, Mayor Michael P. Summers laid out the rationale for his decision to be proactive regarding the Lakewood Hospital Crisis. That his decision was widely approved of by community leaders was patently obvious. Whether it was the "right" decision or not will be a subjective call for history to answer, but one thing was quite certain in my mind as I reflected on the minutes-long applause. The fight for Lakewood Hospital... was over."

Just a couple remarks about this quote.

The Mayor's "Lakewood Hospital Crisis" was completely manufactured by him, the LHA, and the Clinic's marketing machine. There was no "crisis"! Unless you think that the Clinic's obsession to close Lakewood before Avon opens was the "crisis". That would be the Clinic's Avon Hospital "crisis", not Lakewood Hospital's "crisis". Up until 2015, the hospital was profitable. Ask Ernst & Young about it! Sure, it lost money, but it was the PROFIT MARGIN that lost money and the hospital was in no risk of bankruptcy as it had no debt and was in fine shape to continue as a hospital into the future. That's what Shannon Ritchie admitted to in his recent deposition. He admitted he has seen many other hospitals in much worse shape than Lakewood, and they remained viable businesses. Sorry, but the hospital remained a viable business despite the Clinic's best efforts to destroy it from the inside.

The Mayor's decision may have been "widely approved" by city leaders (are you talking about City Council?) but it was not "widely approved" by the people who live in this city. That decision is becoming less and less popular by the day.

Let's see what happens when the citizenry of Lakewood realizes that the "leadership" of this town doesn't give a damn what they say to Council or at the ballot box. Finally, they will realize what kind of person Mayor Summers really is.

Thanks for the post, Gary. It is a good read, if a bit premature in my opinion.
Gary Rice
Posts: 1651
Joined: Wed Aug 23, 2006 9:59 pm
Location: Lakewood

Re: It's Over Now, Dead And Gone...A Hospital Commentary And Reflection...

Post by Gary Rice »

Brian,

Thank you so much for correctly assessing the tone and intent of my quickly-drafted message this morning. I was just wondering whether I should have sent it at all, and perhaps it would have been better erased or, as Cameron points out, left for later.

As we adults all know, these things are complicated. This one is certainly beyond my complete understanding. That's why I qualified my remarks with letting everyone know that they are only my opinions.

As I see it, there are at least four issues here:

1) The biggie...How this was all handled. That needs further attention, no doubt about that in my mind.

2) The old building? Well, like the old schools, a hundred-year old structure needs to be carefully evaluated, particularly if being used for medical purposes. If carefully maintained, I guess it certainly could be. Time will tell about our Lakewood building, regardless of my opinions about it.

3) Keeping "Lakewood Hospital" in Lakewood? (whether in a new or old structure) With every fiber of my being, I hoped and worked for that possibility and perhaps that will still be possible with all the people who are working towards that end. My position in that respect has not changed at all. We NEED a hospital!

4) Trying to bring Lakewood back from the brink of the abyss as a community that needs to heal.

With my own imperfect words, that indeed is the main intent of my post here today. Civility, the right to disagree without incurring rancor...we need that so much here.

At the same time, Brian is absolutely on the money. Peace and justice and TRUTH ALL go hand in hand. Bring them ALL on! :D

All again just my opinions here, and I may be wrong, but... :D

Back to the banjo.. :D
Michael Deneen
Posts: 2133
Joined: Fri Jul 08, 2005 4:10 pm

Re: It's Over Now, Dead And Gone...A Hospital Commentary And Reflection...

Post by Michael Deneen »

Gary has been The Observer's finest writer since the project was launched eleven years ago.
He is not a shill for the mayor, but this piece was a MAJOR miss.

The political and legal process are still going, so I don't think anyone is in position to declare it over.
Also, Hospital Haters will use this piece as a weapon against those that have fought this corrupt deal.

I also think it's time to put away the banjo.
As Brian says: No Justice No Peace
This city has been divided, and will remain so until either the hospital is restored or until the city collapses under the weight of increasingly high taxes.
cmager
Posts: 697
Joined: Fri Feb 19, 2016 8:33 am

Re: It's Over Now, Dead And Gone...A Hospital Commentary And Reflection...

Post by cmager »

Mr. Rice,
I don't believe that popular applause (from a stacked room?) trumps moral and ethical behavior. History is littered with the applause of groups both large and small seeking comfort and salvation from their own weaknesses and actions.

Comity is a great community attribute, but it strikes me that those most demanding of civility and respect and obedience (not you, but those in power) are those whose actions are in question. In this case, their demand is simply a form of evasion, to distract from those seeking the truth. I too err towards civility, but perhaps what you're seeing is a very human difficulty in respecting those who do harm.

And, they would like nothing better than to have you prematurely declare that "it's over now".

regards, c
Dan Alaimo
Posts: 2140
Joined: Fri Apr 23, 2010 8:49 am

Re: It's Over Now, Dead And Gone...A Hospital Commentary And Reflection...

Post by Dan Alaimo »

I greatly appreciate Gary's quick reportage of the event last night. I'd like to see more of that in cases where I can't attend.
To pick up a point made by others, it sounds like the room was packed with the Mayor's (and CCF's and LHA's) supporters. I don't see how applause from such a crowd can be interpreted as city wide support for the hospital deal.
“Never let a good crisis go to waste." - Winston Churchill (Quote later appropriated by Rahm Emanuel)
m buckley
Posts: 708
Joined: Mon Sep 15, 2014 12:52 pm

Re: It's Over Now, Dead And Gone...A Hospital Commentary And Reflection...

Post by m buckley »

cmager wrote:
"Mr. Rice, I don't believe that popular applause ( from a stacked room? ) trumps moral and ethical behavior. History is littered with the applause of groups both large and small seeking comfort and salvation from their own weaknesses and actions.
Comity is a great community attribute, but it strikes me that those demanding of civility and respect and obedience ( not you, but those in power) are those whose actions are in question.
In this case, their demand is simply a form of evasion, to distract from those seeking the truth. I too err towards civility, but perhaps what your seeing is a very human difficulty in respecting those who do harm."

cmager- Thank you for nailing it. Thank you for doing so without any forays into the history of the Civil War and accompanying comparisons with Confederate revisionists.
Your post should be bumped.
" City Council is a 7-member communications army." Colin McEwen December 10, 2015.
Gary Rice
Posts: 1651
Joined: Wed Aug 23, 2006 9:59 pm
Location: Lakewood

Re: It's Over Now, Dead And Gone...A Hospital Commentary And Reflection...

Post by Gary Rice »

Everyone,

I try every day to do what I think is right, but I make no claim to perfection.

Mike and Cameron could well both be right. This column was likely way premature, and maybe I did miss the boat by a nautical mile with this one. Perhaps Dan too has a point about the room being packed with supporters, although there was no way that could be determined, except at the end of the speech.

Factually, I only observed a few red SLH shirts in attendance, as my photographs show. (although there were more outside)

Then when that thunderous applause came, I was absolutely stunned.

I suppose my only thought at that point was, with that kind of unified affirmation, maybe I'd better write a "let's move ahead" peacemaking column for the good of the city, and thereby attempt to put the best face on a difficult situation. No one suggested that I do it. It was just how I felt this morning when I woke up.

I would hope that neither side would try and use an opinion piece for their advantage, particularly so, mine. I have been more than candid concerning my conflicted thoughts with you all about all of this. One way or another, (and as I even indicated in that piece) this is very likely not over yet, and apparently will not be over until it has run its course.

It's not that I need to put the banjo down, Mike, it's just that from time to time, the song changes. Like when Pete Seeger sang those timeless words from the Book of Ecclesiastics about everything having its season...

I hope and pray for the day when the lion lies down with the lamb, but as a pastor friend of mine once and wisely pointed out to me...They do that now, but the trouble is....

...only one of them gets back up. :roll:

Back to the banjo...
Michael Deneen
Posts: 2133
Joined: Fri Jul 08, 2005 4:10 pm

Re: It's Over Now, Dead And Gone...A Hospital Commentary And Reflection...

Post by Michael Deneen »

m buckley wrote:Thank you for doing so without any forays into the history of the Civil War and accompanying comparisons with Confederate revisionists.
Yes, the Confederate analogy was inappropriate, especially in these days of rising racial strife in the US.
However, after 11 years of excellence, Gary is entitled to a mulligan.
Gary Rice
Posts: 1651
Joined: Wed Aug 23, 2006 9:59 pm
Location: Lakewood

Re: It's Over Now, Dead And Gone...A Hospital Commentary And Reflection...

Post by Gary Rice »

Point taken.

I was only hoping to use the South/North stuff to emphasize the Gettysburg reunion idea and relate it to Lakewood getting back together.

Sigh, perhaps my next column should be about toilet paper comparisons... :roll:
Corey Rossen
Posts: 1663
Joined: Thu Nov 09, 2006 12:09 pm

Re: It's Over Now, Dead And Gone...A Hospital Commentary And Reflection...

Post by Corey Rossen »

Gary Rice wrote:Sigh, perhaps my next column should be about toilet paper comparisons... :roll:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jw_F8gJOH5k
Corey Rossen

"I have neither aligned myself with SLH, nor BL." ~ Jim O'Bryan

"I am not neutral." ~Jim O'Bryan

"I am not here to stir up anything." ~Jim O'Bryan
Amy Martin
Posts: 549
Joined: Tue Jun 10, 2014 9:30 am

Re: It's Over Now, Dead And Gone...A Hospital Commentary And Reflection...

Post by Amy Martin »

As much as I hate to see the Hospital gone, I think we all need to accept the fact that it IS gone and we'll never have another hospital on that site.

What we can do now it to make sure that the property is developed wisely, and by that I mean no tax sucking, revenue losing WRECK center
Post Reply