A Christmas Reflection And Analysis Concerning Lakewood...

The jumping off discussion area for the rest of the Deck. All things Lakewood.
Please check out our other sections. As we refile many discussions from the past into
their proper sections please check them out and offer suggestions.

Moderator: Jim O'Bryan

Gary Rice
Posts: 1651
Joined: Wed Aug 23, 2006 9:59 pm
Location: Lakewood

A Christmas Reflection And Analysis Concerning Lakewood...

Post by Gary Rice »

These past few days have provided an opportunity for me to reflect on many things concerning the community that my family adopted in 1958, when we arrived here from western Pennsylvania. Dad had secured a job with the Lakewood Schools. From the beginning, and in so many ways, this town became our home.

Later on, when a goodly number of our friends achieved a certain level of affluence, and credit became easier to obtain, they started to move away to newer homes and distant suburbs.

We remained here, not because we had to, but because we wanted to. Naysayers and fear mongers would have had Lakewood going down the tubes, way back in the '60's. Thanks to the herculean efforts of many people, Lakewood has continued to be an attractive city to live in.

Of course, as with anywhere else in the world, issues always arise that challenge the comfortable present with an unknown future. Sometimes, those issue questions bring forth good things, and sometimes, not. That's just the way life goes.

As we are all aware, the latest Lakewood issue in play has been the question of our hospital.

Quite a few people, including my family, believed that we have seen this hospital crisis coming for a long time. Even those of us who have supported our hospital understand that the way health care is changing today, it would not be reality to expect that a single health care provider should provide duplicate services in multiple hospitals, located just a few miles from each other. This train's been coming for some time now. This just happened to be the year that our community leadership decided to face the problem head on.

Contrary to the opinions of some, I do believe that our present community leadership group was probably boxed in to making the decision that they made. It is my strong belief that normally good, decent, people were forced into this decision by circumstances beyond their control. As such, they may likely attempt to disclaim personal responsibility for outcomes arising from their decision. Quite possibly too, they will be correct.

I cannot, and will not vilify or judge them for the decision they felt that they had to make as our representatives, but it is an even stronger belief on my part that THAT decision, and the process by which it was made, could well now destroy the fragile fabric of whatever positive municipal dynamic that we may have left here in Lakewood.

We need, quite frankly, to address that dynamic going forward, no matter how the hospital thing eventually ends up. We also very MUCH need to be proactive with Lakewood's quality-of-life issues, regardless of what future scenario comes along.

Our municipal government will now have much fence-mending to do with Lakewood's citizens. Whether or not they can repair the tremendous disconnect that was put in play the other night will be the question of our time, and one that may well determine whether or not the heart of Lakewood will ever recover.

Unfortunately, one way or another, a message has been sent, loud and clear, that, as a place to live, Lakewood may not look quite as attractive as it once did. :shock:

In figuring out how I wanted to respond to what has just been decided regarding our hospital, I will frankly admit to having had a very difficult time dealing with what has transpired.

For people of faith, many people, including myself, believe that while we retain our natural "human" reactions, we also have been given a "supernatural" God-given relationship based on God's Love. :D

Now that "human" side of me wanted to put up a for-sale sign and move away from here- sooner than later, shaking the dust from my feet; as the Bible states that one should do when there seems nothing left to be done in a community that may well deserve to be abandoned by God. :shock:

Another "human" reaction for me was to want to dramatically destroy my iconic "Lakewood Observer Banjo" in some public location, as a final rejection of all things positive that my family and I have tried to do for this city. :shock:

As a songwriter, yet another gut-level response that I had was to pen some ironic and nasty Christmas Carol parodies, but it's really not the time to sing, is it? Nor do I feel right about responding to negativity with even more negativity, especially during this time of year.

Is there really a moral high ground left here for any of us in Lakewood? Lakewood's hospital closing advocates will indeed no doubt try to disclaim any personal responsibility for consequences relating to the closing of the hospital, but the fact remains that all of us indeed will likely be so much LESS safe in Lakewood when our hospital is gone, and not so much DIRECTLY because it is gone, but rather INDIRECTLY.

Here's why: When an ambulance arrives at your home these days, it already carries much of what is needed to save your life. The direct connection with a hospital and an ambulance by computer will, in all likelihood, be sufficient to take care of your immediate medical problem, no matter how far away a hospital happens to be. The REAL problem, and the one that I have not yet seen discussed very much, will be simply this one:

Response time. :shock:

When saddled with multiple runs out-of-town to hospitals in other communities, it will simply take LONGER for our first medical responders to arrive at your door, and THAT will likely be where the potential life-or-death situations will arise, BIG time...

...for ALL of us. :shock:

Anyone who voted to close our hospital, anyone who supported the closing of our hospital, needs to know that, in countless life-or-death situations in Lakewood from now on...

...death can happen by DELAY....many times, over and over. Just having one less hospital in our area could also exacerbate that issue exponentially.

At what price indeed can anyone purchase the moral high ground here, much less a purchase a clear conscience; particularly, when the direct effect of one's actions could well have potentially disastrous and fatal consequences in perpetuity?

No, upon reflection I really need to rise beyond those "human" responses to something higher, especially today. :shock:

Specifically, I do not plan to move, nor do I plan to smash up the Lakewood Observer banjo. Nor do I plan to blame anyone personally, or for that matter, do I plan to be negative to anyone. That's just not the way I can be anymore. :D

To each, their own conscience here. We all have to live with ourselves in this life. :shock:

I will rather, with God's help, try to remain positive. Lakewood will need all the positive it can get in the coming year. We still have a VERY good city. There are many other good places to live that are much farther from medical care than the citizens of Lakewood will ever be; even in a worst-case closed-hospital scenario. They survive. We shall too, hopefully. :D

What we will need to work for, now and always, is to continue to SUPPORT our municipal police, fire, and medical response units, perhaps even looking at EXPANDING the number of medical vehicles available. We need to do whatever we can to have rapid-response emergency medical help for all of us close by, at all times. :D

Finally, in the spirit of Christmas, please understand here that I would never claim to always be right, nor to be "holier than thou". I mess up in life just as much as anyone else. I fall short every day, and I may be wrong here in some particulars, but one place that I cannot fall would be now:

One just needs to speak up when circumstances call for it. Particularly when they call for all of us trying to rise above the present, so that we can claim the future :D

Our city's future is indeed at stake, but more importantly, lives are at stake here; ALL of our lives, in fact. :!:

Now, it's Christmas time. :D

Merry Christmas, and Happy Holidays to those who observe non-Christian traditions. :D

In that spirit, why not at least start a healing process by reflecting on this ancient expression:

"Facienti Quod In Se Est Deus Non Denegat Gratiam", which is to mean:
God does not deny grace to those who do what good they can.


Back to the banjo... :D
Brian Essi
Posts: 2421
Joined: Thu May 07, 2015 11:46 am

Re: A Christmas Reflection And Analysis Concerning Lakewood...

Post by Brian Essi »

Gary,

A belated Merry Christmas to you.

I love the banjo string--- computer keyboard combo!!

It seems you agree that there is great human cost to the hospital closure and the those who supported or bear responsibility. I agree. But you also opine that the elected representatives were somehow "boxed in" to their decision. I disagree.

Please note that throughout this ordeal not one elected representative ever stood up and said LHA or CCF were in breach or even that they failed us--facts that are beyond debate. There was no effort at all by the Mayor or City Council to take charge of the assets that belonged to the City or to ever even attempt to hold anyone accountable. None stood up for the poor or weak or the elderly. The contrast to the lesson from the One born on Christmas Day is duly noted.

So in my view if they were "boxed in" they only have themselves to blame for that predicament.

What if in 1940 Winston Churchill said "Oh I'm boxed In let's sign another treaty instead of standing up to what is wrong"?

It's been my experience that leaders who are good at making excuses for not acting are usually not good at leading much less good for anything else.

If pointing out that elected officials are wrong and have failed us is "vilifying" them, then I say bring out the cry babies to have them play victim of the Ogre some more. As always, their ire is a testament to the truths they run from.

They claim to speak in the names of "their" charities but have vilified the good people trying to save the most important charity in Lakewood--all the while promoting the "BIG Dream" of economic development--a development to built (if ever) by stealing from a charity. The fact that has they lack the courage or intellect to challenge the facts about the Master Agreement is self- evident from their silence on black and white economic terms and conditions and their nonsensical blabberings about purported relevancy of democracy.

So we can only pray for these lost souls as is appears that only God himself can open their eyes to the truth.

But this is a time for more than just prayer and words. We will all be judged by our actions and deeds.
David Anderson has no legitimate answers
Lori Allen _
Posts: 2550
Joined: Wed Jan 28, 2015 2:37 pm

Re: A Christmas Reflection And Analysis Concerning Lakewood...

Post by Lori Allen _ »

Sorry guys,
I don't think praying for these people will or would have changed a thing. It appears that Summers, Council, LHA and CCF had this planned out for a long time. You have to feel remorse in order to be forgiven. Does anyone really think that the above mentioned people feel any remorse? No, I believe they all laughed their way to the bank this Christmas. I feel that the only thing these people should have gotten for Christmas was a lump of coal and an orange jump suit! I will sit back now and wait to be tongue lashed!
Gary Rice
Posts: 1651
Joined: Wed Aug 23, 2006 9:59 pm
Location: Lakewood

Re: A Christmas Reflection And Analysis Concerning Lakewood...

Post by Gary Rice »

Brian,Lori:

No tongue-lashing from me. I enjoyed reading your thoughtful remarks.

As far as forgiveness goes? With my limited understanding of Theology, forgiveness is a gift and actually does not require that the one being forgiven be contrite or remorseful of heart. Jesus forgave many very non-contrite people from the cross on Calvary. "Forgive them Father, for they know not what they do" seems to be the way that passage is often translated.

It's that free gift of forgiveness that I believe will change the world.

Remember? Joan Baez sang "I Dreamed I Saw St. Augustine"; Bob Dylan's great song about the Saint who was searching for the souls who already had been sold.

Being in a spirit of forgiveness or of faith however should not imply submission or weakness in any way. The struggle to save the hospital will surely go on, whether in this forum or perhaps in the courts, or in the court of public opinion certainly. More than these places of struggle, the greater struggle, I would hope, would be in the hearts of us all.

One should never discount the power of prayer, but faith and prayer, (as history has shown over and over again) have also been clarion calls for action. One cannot love without living for others, and particularly for those less fortunate. Lakewood showed that last year with their passionate care and concern for snow shoveling as my dad did when he helped me write that song about it, practically with his last breath.

As I wrote in my post, the "human" side of me wanted to do BITTER things, but the loving side of me tells me to do the BETTER things: Rise, remain, reflect, and retort. :wink:

I love that old Quaker thought about how Peter said this and Paul said that, but now that they are both dead, (and this being our time) what should WE now be saying and doing? God just has us, after all. :shock:

What SHOULD we now be saying and doing, indeed? :idea:

Back to the banjo... :D
Brian Essi
Posts: 2421
Joined: Thu May 07, 2015 11:46 am

Re: A Christmas Reflection And Analysis Concerning Lakewood...

Post by Brian Essi »

Not sure either of you got my drift.

Anyway since the subject has changed to forgiveness---I believe that Forgiveness is mostly about helping the one doing the forgiving. It is about letting go. It does not necessarily require the victimizer to seek forgiveness.

At the same time, forgiveness does not require us to allow the victimizer to continue the behavior and just simply forgive them. So if someone has a knife in your back and is twisting it, forgiveness may not be a healthy "solution".

In the hospital situation, the knife is still turning.

I believe it was Mother Teresa who said "love and truth go hand in hand. Love without truth breeds compromise and sentimentality. Truth without love breeds harshness and violence."

There has been no love or compromise from the "majority" nor has there been anything close to truth.

So Lakeowood is in a very bad place
Right now. Any attempt at acceptance of this result ignores the truth. Yet adherence to the truth will bring harshness and violence.

And harshness and violence is exactly what the "majority" has dealt to the most vulnerable among us.

So where do the "good" people of
Lakewood go from here?
David Anderson has no legitimate answers
Gary Rice
Posts: 1651
Joined: Wed Aug 23, 2006 9:59 pm
Location: Lakewood

Re: A Christmas Reflection And Analysis Concerning Lakewood...

Post by Gary Rice »

Just a few more opinionated reflections, going forward into the new year. :D

First, the meditation, sometimes attributed to the Dalai Lama, Harriet Tubman, and others about if a person thinks they are too small to make a difference in life, they should think about the effect that a little mosquito has on a big human being. :shock:

Secondly, this quote, attributed to Harriet Tubman:

"I freed a thousand slaves. I could have freed a thousand more, if only they knew they were slaves."

:roll:

For example, sometimes, fellow Lakewoodites, it's not the persuading that works in an argument. It's the personal experience that counts... :shock:

Rich or poor, we shall all take our turn on that medical roulette wheel, sooner or later... :shock:

...and critical medical care IS personal experience indeed. Real personal... :roll:

Unfortunately, for many of those people who have supported getting rid of the hospital, by the time they too will need it, it may be too late at that point for them to change their opinion on the subject. :shock:

Just my opinion here, but I've never seen a group of people lose so much by "winning".... :shock:

Just a few reflections while sitting here getting ready for the new year, wondering whether some old acquaintances should be forgot or not... :lol:

Back to the banjo... :D
Marguerite Harkness
Posts: 293
Joined: Thu May 14, 2015 10:42 am

Re: A Christmas Reflection And Analysis Concerning Lakewood...

Post by Marguerite Harkness »

Gary: "Medical roulette wheel" - you nailed it!
Post Reply