Re: America's Best High School
Posted: Tue Jul 06, 2010 9:40 pm
There are very few “effective” high schools in the U.S., at least insofar as facing 21st century challenges is concerned. None are traditional schools. The two biggest problems with traditional schools are:
1) Traditional schools assume that “success” is when you are smarter than everyone else. The fact is, success is when everyone else is just as smart as you. Hopefully even smarter. We teach kids to compete (via grades), not to collaborate. Unfortunately....
2) Traditional schools punish failure, when in fact you learn more from failure than you ever do from success. Getting a question wrong costs you? Failure should be rewarded.
I won't bother mentioning the premise that one singular educational model is most appropriate for virtually all students. Or that memorizing stuff is more important than making/fixing stuff. Or that the “subject matter” educational model we use today was designed at the height of the Industrial Revolution.
The educational system we use today isn't working. How? I can't tell you. All I can tell you is that our economy is in the worst shape in 80 years and maybe forever, the environment is in the worst shape ever, we are barreling through non-renewable resources at an alarming rate and jeopardizing those we purport to educate, we're at war in two countries, corruption at all levels is rampant, we pass 2000-page laws that even their authors don't understand, our justice system is broken, Social Security/Medicare/public employee pensions are toast, and we are becoming increasingly morally and intellectually bankrupt. Even as we allegedly get “smarter.”
With all the problems we face today, and with virtually nobody paying serious attention, young or old, how can it be said that our educational system does, or really ever did (at least recently), put out an effective product? If our kids were truly educated there would be a perpetual Million Teen March demanding we fix things. But our kids are way too apathetic. My generation ended Vietnam. My kids, not so much....
1) Traditional schools assume that “success” is when you are smarter than everyone else. The fact is, success is when everyone else is just as smart as you. Hopefully even smarter. We teach kids to compete (via grades), not to collaborate. Unfortunately....
2) Traditional schools punish failure, when in fact you learn more from failure than you ever do from success. Getting a question wrong costs you? Failure should be rewarded.
I won't bother mentioning the premise that one singular educational model is most appropriate for virtually all students. Or that memorizing stuff is more important than making/fixing stuff. Or that the “subject matter” educational model we use today was designed at the height of the Industrial Revolution.
The educational system we use today isn't working. How? I can't tell you. All I can tell you is that our economy is in the worst shape in 80 years and maybe forever, the environment is in the worst shape ever, we are barreling through non-renewable resources at an alarming rate and jeopardizing those we purport to educate, we're at war in two countries, corruption at all levels is rampant, we pass 2000-page laws that even their authors don't understand, our justice system is broken, Social Security/Medicare/public employee pensions are toast, and we are becoming increasingly morally and intellectually bankrupt. Even as we allegedly get “smarter.”
With all the problems we face today, and with virtually nobody paying serious attention, young or old, how can it be said that our educational system does, or really ever did (at least recently), put out an effective product? If our kids were truly educated there would be a perpetual Million Teen March demanding we fix things. But our kids are way too apathetic. My generation ended Vietnam. My kids, not so much....