Re: Potholes: Is Summers First, Subjects Second?
Posted: Sat Apr 15, 2017 11:57 am
A friend of mine sent me a text today asking if I had seen the claims made by Lori Allen about pothole patching and street resurfacing on the Observation Deck – I used to be a contributor to the Lakewood Observer years ago, but I don’t come here much anymore, perhaps once every one or two months just to take a cursory look.
Every single claim made by Lori Allen in this thread is simply false. False do such a degree that it merits a response based on facts to set the record straight.
I don’t know how to really use the deck format – nor do I really care to invest the time in that I rarely visit this site and may never post again, or at the very least not for a very long time. I’ll just respond in order to Ms. Allen’s falsehoods and outright lies and respond with facts below each one.
1) Ms. Allen made the following FALSE CLAIM:
“It has come to my attention that either Friday or sometime over the weekend, Wilbert Rd. was patched all the way through from Lake to Cliff Dr. They even patched by the catch basins, water valves, and all the way from curb to curb.” ….and “Did Summers' call and complain about his street? I don't know for sure. However, it would be typical of a Lord such as Lord Lakewood to put himself first and his subjects and serfs last.”
THE FACT IS: The reason that Wilbert, Nicholson and Edgewater to Lakewood Park were patched early was for the sole reason to protect all the runners that participated in the April 8th St. Edward Eagle’s Run 5K race. So yes, we were very meticulous in making sure we alleviated any potential for an ankle injury and/or fall so that none of the runners would get injured due to any road surface defects. That’s it – no vast conspiracy, just concern for public safety and that the race would be a pleasant experience for all.
We do the same for Lake Ave., it gets meticulously patched early due to the many road races that are run on that street beginning in April. Lakewood has a very active any dynamic running community and hosts over 12 races each year that are run on portions of Lake Ave – including a portion of the Cleveland Marathon and its 8,000 plus runners who run through our great city. It is estimated that over 20,000 runners participate in a road race within Lakewood each year.
2) Ms. Allen made the following FALSE CLAIM:
"I don't ever remember a time in Lakewood when our streets were not patched this long after winter. I don't know if there's no money for patch or if Summers laid off more of our city workers."
THE FACT IS: The asphalt plants typically do not open until the first or second week in April for “hot mix” asphalt patching material to apply to roadways for a more long term pothole fill and patch to degraded surfaces – this year it opened on April 3, 2017. During the winter months we use cold patch as a temporary patch measure that needs to be applied to the same problem areas multiple times each winter season. We do Lake Ave and any other road running race streets first, as mentioned above, address the largest known potholes citywide and then strategically move on to the most heavily traveled worst streets and then on to side streets in general.
THE FACT IS: To address Ms. Allen’s falsehood – the past two years we have completed all asphalt patching earlier than in the preceding 5 years. We anticipate that to be the same this year since we have resurfaced more city streets than ever before (more on that below). This has allowed us to do more crack sealing across the city to better preserve pavement surfaces long term.
3) Ms. Allen made the following FALSE CLAIM:
In regards to street resurfacing, these are the streets being paved this year:
- Leedale
- Erie Cliff
- Lake Point Dr. (ex-school board member, LHF member, and good friend of Summers lives here, street is not even bad)
- Athens from Belle to Warren (Dru Siley's street, go drive down it, it is not bad)
- Andrews (only from tracks to Detroit, school board member's street)
- Chase (a couple of Summers' friends live down here)
- Merl from Manor Park to Bunts (this should be done)
- Elbur from Clifton to Merl
- Chesterland from Franklin to Madison (John Litten's street)
- Leonard
- Shaw
- Northwood (street is very bad, but should have waited until Mckinley Place is done so heavy trucks don't tear up the road)
- Newman from Franklin to Madison (this should be done)
- Delaware from Carabel to Arthur (at least one alleged mayor's friend lives here)
- Richland (a couple of LakewoodAlive people and Summers' friends live down here, but street is bad)
- Hall from Lake to Clifton
THE FACT IS: These are the streets we resurfaced LAST YEAR in 2016 – selected based on the worst pavement ratings and conditions and some in conjunction with water main replacement projects. All your personal attacks against fellow Lakewood residents who live on those are baseless and again – they were all done last year.
4)Ms. Allen made the following FALSE CLAIM:
"I notice that they are holding off on paving Brown AGAIN. The only reason I can think of that this is not being paved is because there is an older gentleman and war veteran that lives down here. He is always complaining about his street and how it floods every rain. They have allegedly had armed guards throw him out of city hall a few times because they didn't like him asking questions. Not to be morbid, but are they waiting until this gentleman passes away on purpose so he can't enjoy a smooth street? Rumor has it that City Hall was harassing him at his home a while back."
THE FACT IS: Brown is getting resurfaced this year. The reason we had to delay the street to do this year and not do it last year is that this year we are also going to replace the water main. If a water main is due for replacement in one to three years, we are not going to resurface that street only the tear it up again in a couple years – we combine, when we can, the resurfacing of certain poorer pavement conditions streets with necessary water main replacement projects to save costs and protect our infrastructure. Many of the residents on Brown know this.
5)Ms. Allen made the following FALSE CLAIM:
"Last year, Kenneth was paved. This is not a heavily-traveled street and it could have waited. However, one of the mayor's secretaries and a couple other mayor friend's live down there."
THE FACT IS: This was resurfaced in 2015 and not last year – based on the fact that it had one of the worst pavement ratings and conditions in the city at that time and city crews were spending an inordinate amount of time patching it and trying to hold it together.
6)Ms. Allen made the following FALSE CLAIM:
"If you go back at the streets paved, you will notice that the total miles of streets paved each year has decreased during the Summers administration."
The is the worst falsehood of all – Kellyanne Conway could not top this one.
THE FACT IS: In 2016, the City of Lakewood had the highest number of streets to ever be resurfaced in one year. It surpassed the old record for number of streets set in 2015. None of these were meaningless chip seal short life span/short term fixes done 10-15 years ago, but rather deep grind major resurfacing projects the will last a very long time.
We are doing the following in 2017 - another very large resurfacing project once again eclipsing greatly what was done a decade ago, some including new water mains as part of the overall scope of work. Note: a couple poor pavement condition streets not shown below will be done in the next 1-2 years in conjunction with necessary water main replacements:
Brown - All
Cranford - Clifton to Detroit
Lincoln - Detroit to Lakewood Hts
Marlow - Detroit to Madison
Hopkins - All
Clarence - Hazelwood to Madison
Elbur - Detroit to Franklin
Mars - Athens to Delaware
Olive - All
Northland - Margaret to Delaware
Margaret - All
Olivewood - Franklin to Cedarwood
Wilbert - Cliff to Lake
THE FACT IS: Below is brief history of what city streets have been resurfaced the past four years – it is impressive to say the least, not to mention all the water main replacements and the elimination of a number of combined sewer overflow outfalls, etc, etc, etc. :
2016 Streets Paved (Highest number of streets to ever be re-surfaced in Lakewood in one year)
Athens - Warren to Belle
Erie Cliff - Lake to North Terminus
Lake Point - Lake to North Terminus
Leedale - Lake to Edgewater
Leonard - Warren to Belle
Mars - Madison to Hilliard
Northwood - West Clifton to Granger
Shaw - Granger to West Terminus
Delaware - Carabel to Arthur
Richland - Madison to Lakewood Hts.
Chesterland - Madison to Franklin
Andrews - Railroad tracks to detroit
Hall - Clifton to Lake
Concord - Hilliard to Riverway
Cranford - Detroit to Clifton
FULL DEPTH CONCRETE
McKinley - North Marginal Intersection
McKinley - South Marginal Intersection -
W. 117th St. - Berea Rd. area
W. 117th St. - Madison Ave. area
WATER MAIN REPLACEMENTS
Alameda - Detroit to Franklin Asphalt Replacement
Robinwood - Madison to High School Asphalt Repairs
Lakeland - Madison to Athens Asphalt Repairs
Morrison - Madison to Athens Asphalt Repairs
CDBG WATER MAIN REPLACEMENT
Chase - Merl to Clifton
CDBG STREETS PAVED
Chase - Merl to Clifton
Elbur - Merl to Clifton
Merl - Manor Park to Bunts
Newman - Madison to Franklin
2015 Streets Paved
Coutant - Franklin to Detroit
Lark - Madison to Plover
Thrush - Halstead to Magee
Madison - 117th to Riverside
Arthur - Madison to Hilliard
Carabel - Hilliard to Lkwd Hts.
Cliffdale - Lake to Edgewater
Cranford - Clifton to Lake
Edgewater - W. 117th to Cove
Edwards - Clifton to Lake
Garfield - Warren to Lincoln
Kenneth - Lake to North Terminus
Maile - Detroit to Riverside
Ogontz - Fischer to North Terminus
Owego - Detroit to Maile
Rockway - Detroit to Franklin
Sloane Subway - Sloane to Lake Rd.
St. Charles - Madison to Franklin
South Marginal - McKinley to Woodward
St. Charles - Detroit to Franklin
Woodward - Hilliard to North Marginal
Blossom Park - Franklin to Cedarwood
Athens - Belle to Brown
2014 Streets Paved
Archdale - Larchmont to Riverside
Atkins - Fischer to South Marginal
Franklin - Larchmont to Riverside
Nicholson - Detroit to Clifton
North Marginal East - Woodward to Atkins
North Marginal West - Niagara to Hilliard
Seneca - Ogontz to East terminus
South Marginal West - Hilliard to I-90 Exit Ramp
South Marginal East - Woodward to Corporate Line
Clifton Bridge Approach
2013 Streets Paved
Arthur - Detroit to North Terminus
Cove - Lake to Edgewater
Cove - Clifton to Lake
Eldred - Delaware to Hilliard
Lakeland - Hilliard to Detroit
Lakeland - Clifton to Lake
Lewis - Franklin to Madison
Marlowe - Athens to Madison
McKinley - Hilliard to North Marginal
Northland - Madison to Detroit
Summit - Clifton to Lake
Westwood - Hilliard to Madison
Woodward - Hilliard to Madison
Woodward - South Marginal to Fischer
Wyandotte - Franklin to Madison
Lakewood is a Great Community - Proud to be part of it!
Respectfully,
Chris Perry
Streets and Forestry Division Manager, Arborist
City of Lakewood
Every single claim made by Lori Allen in this thread is simply false. False do such a degree that it merits a response based on facts to set the record straight.
I don’t know how to really use the deck format – nor do I really care to invest the time in that I rarely visit this site and may never post again, or at the very least not for a very long time. I’ll just respond in order to Ms. Allen’s falsehoods and outright lies and respond with facts below each one.
1) Ms. Allen made the following FALSE CLAIM:
“It has come to my attention that either Friday or sometime over the weekend, Wilbert Rd. was patched all the way through from Lake to Cliff Dr. They even patched by the catch basins, water valves, and all the way from curb to curb.” ….and “Did Summers' call and complain about his street? I don't know for sure. However, it would be typical of a Lord such as Lord Lakewood to put himself first and his subjects and serfs last.”
THE FACT IS: The reason that Wilbert, Nicholson and Edgewater to Lakewood Park were patched early was for the sole reason to protect all the runners that participated in the April 8th St. Edward Eagle’s Run 5K race. So yes, we were very meticulous in making sure we alleviated any potential for an ankle injury and/or fall so that none of the runners would get injured due to any road surface defects. That’s it – no vast conspiracy, just concern for public safety and that the race would be a pleasant experience for all.
We do the same for Lake Ave., it gets meticulously patched early due to the many road races that are run on that street beginning in April. Lakewood has a very active any dynamic running community and hosts over 12 races each year that are run on portions of Lake Ave – including a portion of the Cleveland Marathon and its 8,000 plus runners who run through our great city. It is estimated that over 20,000 runners participate in a road race within Lakewood each year.
2) Ms. Allen made the following FALSE CLAIM:
"I don't ever remember a time in Lakewood when our streets were not patched this long after winter. I don't know if there's no money for patch or if Summers laid off more of our city workers."
THE FACT IS: The asphalt plants typically do not open until the first or second week in April for “hot mix” asphalt patching material to apply to roadways for a more long term pothole fill and patch to degraded surfaces – this year it opened on April 3, 2017. During the winter months we use cold patch as a temporary patch measure that needs to be applied to the same problem areas multiple times each winter season. We do Lake Ave and any other road running race streets first, as mentioned above, address the largest known potholes citywide and then strategically move on to the most heavily traveled worst streets and then on to side streets in general.
THE FACT IS: To address Ms. Allen’s falsehood – the past two years we have completed all asphalt patching earlier than in the preceding 5 years. We anticipate that to be the same this year since we have resurfaced more city streets than ever before (more on that below). This has allowed us to do more crack sealing across the city to better preserve pavement surfaces long term.
3) Ms. Allen made the following FALSE CLAIM:
In regards to street resurfacing, these are the streets being paved this year:
- Leedale
- Erie Cliff
- Lake Point Dr. (ex-school board member, LHF member, and good friend of Summers lives here, street is not even bad)
- Athens from Belle to Warren (Dru Siley's street, go drive down it, it is not bad)
- Andrews (only from tracks to Detroit, school board member's street)
- Chase (a couple of Summers' friends live down here)
- Merl from Manor Park to Bunts (this should be done)
- Elbur from Clifton to Merl
- Chesterland from Franklin to Madison (John Litten's street)
- Leonard
- Shaw
- Northwood (street is very bad, but should have waited until Mckinley Place is done so heavy trucks don't tear up the road)
- Newman from Franklin to Madison (this should be done)
- Delaware from Carabel to Arthur (at least one alleged mayor's friend lives here)
- Richland (a couple of LakewoodAlive people and Summers' friends live down here, but street is bad)
- Hall from Lake to Clifton
THE FACT IS: These are the streets we resurfaced LAST YEAR in 2016 – selected based on the worst pavement ratings and conditions and some in conjunction with water main replacement projects. All your personal attacks against fellow Lakewood residents who live on those are baseless and again – they were all done last year.
4)Ms. Allen made the following FALSE CLAIM:
"I notice that they are holding off on paving Brown AGAIN. The only reason I can think of that this is not being paved is because there is an older gentleman and war veteran that lives down here. He is always complaining about his street and how it floods every rain. They have allegedly had armed guards throw him out of city hall a few times because they didn't like him asking questions. Not to be morbid, but are they waiting until this gentleman passes away on purpose so he can't enjoy a smooth street? Rumor has it that City Hall was harassing him at his home a while back."
THE FACT IS: Brown is getting resurfaced this year. The reason we had to delay the street to do this year and not do it last year is that this year we are also going to replace the water main. If a water main is due for replacement in one to three years, we are not going to resurface that street only the tear it up again in a couple years – we combine, when we can, the resurfacing of certain poorer pavement conditions streets with necessary water main replacement projects to save costs and protect our infrastructure. Many of the residents on Brown know this.
5)Ms. Allen made the following FALSE CLAIM:
"Last year, Kenneth was paved. This is not a heavily-traveled street and it could have waited. However, one of the mayor's secretaries and a couple other mayor friend's live down there."
THE FACT IS: This was resurfaced in 2015 and not last year – based on the fact that it had one of the worst pavement ratings and conditions in the city at that time and city crews were spending an inordinate amount of time patching it and trying to hold it together.
6)Ms. Allen made the following FALSE CLAIM:
"If you go back at the streets paved, you will notice that the total miles of streets paved each year has decreased during the Summers administration."
The is the worst falsehood of all – Kellyanne Conway could not top this one.
THE FACT IS: In 2016, the City of Lakewood had the highest number of streets to ever be resurfaced in one year. It surpassed the old record for number of streets set in 2015. None of these were meaningless chip seal short life span/short term fixes done 10-15 years ago, but rather deep grind major resurfacing projects the will last a very long time.
We are doing the following in 2017 - another very large resurfacing project once again eclipsing greatly what was done a decade ago, some including new water mains as part of the overall scope of work. Note: a couple poor pavement condition streets not shown below will be done in the next 1-2 years in conjunction with necessary water main replacements:
Brown - All
Cranford - Clifton to Detroit
Lincoln - Detroit to Lakewood Hts
Marlow - Detroit to Madison
Hopkins - All
Clarence - Hazelwood to Madison
Elbur - Detroit to Franklin
Mars - Athens to Delaware
Olive - All
Northland - Margaret to Delaware
Margaret - All
Olivewood - Franklin to Cedarwood
Wilbert - Cliff to Lake
THE FACT IS: Below is brief history of what city streets have been resurfaced the past four years – it is impressive to say the least, not to mention all the water main replacements and the elimination of a number of combined sewer overflow outfalls, etc, etc, etc. :
2016 Streets Paved (Highest number of streets to ever be re-surfaced in Lakewood in one year)
Athens - Warren to Belle
Erie Cliff - Lake to North Terminus
Lake Point - Lake to North Terminus
Leedale - Lake to Edgewater
Leonard - Warren to Belle
Mars - Madison to Hilliard
Northwood - West Clifton to Granger
Shaw - Granger to West Terminus
Delaware - Carabel to Arthur
Richland - Madison to Lakewood Hts.
Chesterland - Madison to Franklin
Andrews - Railroad tracks to detroit
Hall - Clifton to Lake
Concord - Hilliard to Riverway
Cranford - Detroit to Clifton
FULL DEPTH CONCRETE
McKinley - North Marginal Intersection
McKinley - South Marginal Intersection -
W. 117th St. - Berea Rd. area
W. 117th St. - Madison Ave. area
WATER MAIN REPLACEMENTS
Alameda - Detroit to Franklin Asphalt Replacement
Robinwood - Madison to High School Asphalt Repairs
Lakeland - Madison to Athens Asphalt Repairs
Morrison - Madison to Athens Asphalt Repairs
CDBG WATER MAIN REPLACEMENT
Chase - Merl to Clifton
CDBG STREETS PAVED
Chase - Merl to Clifton
Elbur - Merl to Clifton
Merl - Manor Park to Bunts
Newman - Madison to Franklin
2015 Streets Paved
Coutant - Franklin to Detroit
Lark - Madison to Plover
Thrush - Halstead to Magee
Madison - 117th to Riverside
Arthur - Madison to Hilliard
Carabel - Hilliard to Lkwd Hts.
Cliffdale - Lake to Edgewater
Cranford - Clifton to Lake
Edgewater - W. 117th to Cove
Edwards - Clifton to Lake
Garfield - Warren to Lincoln
Kenneth - Lake to North Terminus
Maile - Detroit to Riverside
Ogontz - Fischer to North Terminus
Owego - Detroit to Maile
Rockway - Detroit to Franklin
Sloane Subway - Sloane to Lake Rd.
St. Charles - Madison to Franklin
South Marginal - McKinley to Woodward
St. Charles - Detroit to Franklin
Woodward - Hilliard to North Marginal
Blossom Park - Franklin to Cedarwood
Athens - Belle to Brown
2014 Streets Paved
Archdale - Larchmont to Riverside
Atkins - Fischer to South Marginal
Franklin - Larchmont to Riverside
Nicholson - Detroit to Clifton
North Marginal East - Woodward to Atkins
North Marginal West - Niagara to Hilliard
Seneca - Ogontz to East terminus
South Marginal West - Hilliard to I-90 Exit Ramp
South Marginal East - Woodward to Corporate Line
Clifton Bridge Approach
2013 Streets Paved
Arthur - Detroit to North Terminus
Cove - Lake to Edgewater
Cove - Clifton to Lake
Eldred - Delaware to Hilliard
Lakeland - Hilliard to Detroit
Lakeland - Clifton to Lake
Lewis - Franklin to Madison
Marlowe - Athens to Madison
McKinley - Hilliard to North Marginal
Northland - Madison to Detroit
Summit - Clifton to Lake
Westwood - Hilliard to Madison
Woodward - Hilliard to Madison
Woodward - South Marginal to Fischer
Wyandotte - Franklin to Madison
Lakewood is a Great Community - Proud to be part of it!
Respectfully,
Chris Perry
Streets and Forestry Division Manager, Arborist
City of Lakewood